JANUARY-JUNE 1965
Malcolm Thomas and Eve Morris fell into a love affair, but Malcolm two-timed her with Cookie. Eve convinced Malcolm to manage her theatre, and they planned their first stage production. Malcolm's relationship with Eve was complicated by the arrival of his ex-wife Kitty DeSena, who won the lead role in the play. Kitty attempted to rekindle her relationship with Malcolm, but he assured her that it would never work.
With Gerry's trial going badly, Mike and Bill convinced Ann Kelly to help them set a trap for Lloyd Griffin. Griffin met Ann at Otto Zimmerman's club when she hinted that she had evidence to link him to Davey Hansen's murder. Ann tricked Lloyd into confessing while Mike and Bill secretly listened. Lloyd pulled a gun and escaped onto the roof of the club, with Bill in pursuit. Bill and Lloyd had a shootout on the roof. While attempting to kill Bill, Lloyd slipped on a rain-slickened fire escape and fell to his death.
Under pressure from Cookie, Malcolm agreed to elope, but was unable to break off his affair with Eve. On the pretext of not hurting her family, Malcolm persuaded Cookie to keep their marriage a secret, though he was more worried about Eve's reaction.
Gerry was cleared of Davey's murder, while Bill was reinstated as Chief-of-Police. Bill married his secretary Martha Spears.
Beth Anderson spotted Malcolm and Eve going into a cheap motel and told Cookie. Cookie confronted Malcolm, who admitted that he was having an affair with Eve. After a violent argument, Cookie left. A drunken Malcolm called Eve and told her he had something very important to tell her. Eve was stunned by news of Malcolm's secret marriage. When Malcolm insisted they end their affair because he truly loved Cookie, Eve went insane with jealousy and stabbed him in the back with a pair of Cookie's scissors.
Winston left for an extended business trip in France. Eve blew Monticello for Mexico where she joined Miguel, a former lover. The discovery of Cookie's marriage to Malcolm and his womanizing prompted the police to arrest Cookie for Malcolm's murder. Cookie was indicted by the Grand Jury and went on trial with Mike defending her. Mike suspected Eve killed Malcolm because he wanted to end their relationship.
Lee and Beth became engaged, but while Lee was away at architectural school, Beth developed an attraction to John Barnes.