DECEMBER 1973
Widows, Geraldine and Tiffany return to Monticello. Geraldine realizes that they must try to put themselves back together, so to speak, and go on living, but Tiffany feels she'll never recover. Fearing that mourning will become Tiffany's whole life, Geraldine invites Nancy to visit ,hoping she can draw Tiffany out of herself. Unable to even see a guest, Tiffany escapes to her room. Geraldine hires John and Trudy, Orin Hillyer's former butler and maid.
Vic practically destroyed after hearing Laurie testifying to "an affair" with Johnny Dallas has been drinking steadily and morosely. Laurie is frantic that Vic has not returned home. The next day Vic comes home for his clothes, and Laurie makes him read the letter of explanation which he overlooked before rushing to court yesterday. Afterward Vic agrees to go out for coffee to talk it out, but when he answers the phone and finds Johnny is calling, he wordlessly walks out. Ironically Johnny was calling to tell Laurie that he has seen Vic and he is all right. Kay Reynolds seeks Vic, and expressing regret that her suspicions about Laurie and Johnny were true, offers him any consolation he'd like. He tells Kay it has hit him so hard that he can't go home back to Laurie. Meanwhile, Lauire is depressed and believes that her marriage is over. When Vic and Laurie accidentally meet he makes it clear he feels she is involved with Johnny and mentions that Kay reminded him he's a good divorce lawyer. He adds that he is not actually ready to talk divorce but he is not ready to think about reconciliation either. Laurie visits Johnny at the restaurant to talk about Vic, then Vic and Kay walk in for lunch. Johnny coolly suggests that they be adult about this and all have lunch together. Laurie says she is not that sophisticated and runs out.
Mike Karr rests the defense case for Adam and is badly depressed that he did not a strong convincing closing argument.
In San Francisco, Kevin confronts Joel about changing the time on his watch the night of the murder. Joel replies that he was only testing Kevin's powers of observation as a detective, and Kevin can't shake this story as there is no motive to tie Joel to the murder. However, when Lucy Wilson slips and mentions Jake was their stepfather and that Joel is her brother, Kevin realizes that Joel's motive was revenge for Jake killing Joel's mother Edith. Changing the time provided Joel's alibi. Kevin confronts Joel with the theory. Realizing that Kevin will go to the police, Joel pulls a gun on him and forces him to drive to a deserted cemetery, where he and Lucy used to bury their dead pets. At gunpoint, Joel forces Kevin to dig his own grave.
Worried by Kevin's prolonged disappearance, Phoebe calls Bill in Monticello who has the San Francisco PD put an APB out for Joel. She then calls Lucy and tells her Kevin's theory. Lucy can't believe the story, but after she discovers that Joel's gun is gone from his desk, she recalls Joel's lifelong lack of emotion over cruelty and his impassiveness toward killing. Lucy then remembers the graveyard and drives there with Phoebe. They arrive just as Kevin, trying to escape, is shot in the leg by Joel. Lucy manages to stop him from killing Kevin, and he gives her the gun, realizing that it is all over. They take Kevin to the hospital where his injury is found to be not serious. Joel signs a full confession. Back in Monticello, Judge Blackwell rushes through an immediate release for Adam, who hurries home to his overjoyed wife, Nicole. Mike asks Adam to rejoin the law firm again as his partner once again.
Geraldine Whitney realizes Adam has the same charisma and quality Colin did, and after having his background checked, she tells Tiffany that Adam could go far. Geraldine remarks that she is going to do Adam the biggest favor of his life.