AUGUST 1973
Now that Kay has concrete proof of his infidelity, Ashley Reynolds tells Phoebe that he is not contesting the divorce so that he can marry her! Phoebe orders him to get out of her life. Kay engages Vic Lamont to handle the divorce now that her attorney Jake Berman is dead. Kay stresses how impressed she is with Vic's ability and intelligence and how much she enjoys talking with him.
D.A. Peter Quinn orders Adam's arrest for Jake's murder immediately following Adam's wedding ceremony to Nicole. After Adam and Nicole are married at the Karr home, Adam is quickly taken into custody. Ironically, Kevin Jamison and Joel Gantry, the only other logical suspects in the case, are alibis for each other, as they were together during the raid of Ashley Reynolds' motel room, where they were gathering evidence for the Reynolds divorce case.
Since Adam's missing gun is a major factor in the case, Laurie asks Johnny to admit that he stole the gun under Jake's orders. Johnny points out that this is a felony and explains that once he starts talking, it would soon come out that she was with him in the Chicago hotel room the afternoon before the murder. Johnny's guilt is compounded when Vic generously offers financial help if Johnny wants to buy The New Moon Cafe. Meanwhile, Johnny makes sure 'the lid is on' in Chicago, so that no one can ever learn of Laurie's presence there. Laurie quits her piano job at the New Moon, and although consumed with guilt, she is convinced she could never tell Vic what happened in Chicago without destroying her marriage.
Adam is indicted for Jake's murder and prepares to stand trial for the crime. Adam hires Mike Karr and Vic Lamont to represent the defense. Mike and Vic trace a medical book inexplicably found in Jake's apartment and are amazed to discover that Johnny bought the book. Pressed by Vic, Johnny admits that Jake used him as an errand boy by blackmailing him for the robbery he pulled on Jake right after being released from prison. Since Vic knew about the robbery, he is satisfied with Johnny's story. Jake's neighbor Mrs. Greening tells the prosecution that Adam broke down the door before the fatal gunshot was heard. When Nicole and Vic plead with her to think carefully, Mrs. Greening realizes she was wrong... the shot was fired first. Quinn's office is furious and accuses Vic of suborning a witness, which he vehemently denies. Judge Blackwell decides to rule on whether Mrs. Greening will be allowed to testify at all.
D.A. Quinn's opening statement professes Adam to be a respected citizen and prestigious attorney, but suggests that Jake's murder was a crime of passion over Nicole. Quinn implies that Nicole could have disposed of the gun and then cites Jake's letter, which accuses Adam of jealous threats and violence.
Mike Karr's opening statement counters that a man of Adam's prestige and honor doesn't perform the cowardly act Quinn described for the flimsiest of motives. Also, Quinn calls Nicole an accomplice, but she was not indicted as there's no proof of culpability. Mike closes by stating that the defense will prove Jake Berman's psychotic personality.
On the witness stand, Officer Santana professionally testifies to Adam's presence at Jake's apartment building and to his anger. Evelyn Barcheck, a secretary in Jake's office building, claims on the witness stand that Jake and Nicole were intimately chummy in public, but Mike proves her to be a bitter old maid, venomously jealous of Nicole. But when Jake's New York associate George Leeds testifies that Jake wanted to marry Nicole and admits that Jake and Nicole could have stayed together in his New York apartment in his absence, Quinn delightfully reiterates Leeds' testimony, implying an affair between Jake and Nicole. Quinn genially suggests that Nicole take the stand to defend herself, while he suprises Nancy Karr with a subpoena as State's witness.
Kevin is stunned to learn that Joel illegally bugged Jake's apartment in his investigation for Edith's daughter, Joel's girlfriend. From the wiretap, Joel gets proof in Jake's own words that he murdered Edith. Also on the tape is Johnny's arrival at Jake's apartment for "target practice". As Joel won't let Kevin borrow the illegal tape, Kevin secretly removes it from Joel's office. He and Phoebe take it to Vic, but he is out. When Laurie learns why they've come, she nervously tries to diminish the importance of the new evidence.